Kyle Hutton and Jeffrey Cole started stealing people at Doverson by luring them into picking them up, only to take out their knives afterwards. One night, Jeffrey was picked by Adam, who offered him $20 for oral sex, but he ended up stealing his wallet. Jeffrey disappeared after that.
The next day, Officers Danny Sofer and Julien Lowe went to Doverson to hand out flyers with Jeffrey's face in it. During their walk, they talked to Kandle, a homosexual prostitute that hadn't seen Jeffrey, and a shop owner who did saw him get inside a car.