Blaine had been tried for pedophilia and was forced to register as a sex offender whenever he moved. When he moved to Farmington, he did so. After some time, he was taken to the Barn, as a suspect for the disappearance of Jeffrey Cole, who lived in the same neighborhood. During interrogation, Detectives Claudette Wyms and Dutch Wagenbach told him someone had seen Jeffrey getting inside his car at 9:30pm the previous night. Blaine told them that couldn't be, because at that time he was having dinner with a group of fellow pedophiles.